Retail Versus Thrift

Since we've looked at how retail is sometimes cheaper than thrifting, we should also do the opposite. Here's a nice lot of embroidery floss at the online thrift auction that appears to be DMC (the numbers on the winders give that away) with approximately 150 skeins. They are used, but not much. The four containers are nice, as are the needles, card sorters and what I believe is a needle minder.

Minimum bid for this lot is $9.99, shipping to me is $19.45, and handling is $3.50. If I won this lot for the minimum bid I would pay $32.94 total, which if my estimate of the number of skeins is correct is about 22 cents per skein. Even with the high price for shipping, this is a solid bargain.

DMC floss is currently $1.15 per skein retail. You can find some bundles on Amazon like this one, but that actually works out to $1.16 per skein, so always figure out the price-per before you buy.

You can find very good bargains in some brick and mortar thrift stores. Here's that bundle of 105 DMC embroidery floss skeins that I recently purchased for $4.18, or about 4 cents per skein.

The main problem with thrifting floss versus buying it new is that you can't choose the colors. You basically just end up with someone else's stash that they donated. So that's a consideration. At the same time, if you can save $1.11 per skein by thrifting, and build up a collection as I have, in time you will acquire almost any color you need. You can also buy retail a few skeins that you aren't able to thrift in the colors you want, which is much cheaper than buying it all new.

One final note about a recent development I've noticed over the last couple years: Embroiderers and resellers have become aware of how cheap vintage floss is going at the online thrift auction, and they are now pouncing on the good listings, so don't ever expect to get it for a song. I imagine that $9.99 minimum bid will increase to $30.00 or even $40.00 by the time the auction ends.* Still, even at double the price I estimated, it's still a bargain. :)

Added: I just checked and the lot went for a final winning bid of $36.00.

Comments

On the Beach

Last week my guy and I went to walk Daytona Beach, which was mostly (and eerily) deserted. This is what our beaches used to look like when I was a kid. It was a beautiful day, cold and breezy but calm. It feels like 2026 is getting off to the right start.

Eight Plus Numbers

When I was looking up the retail on the small lot of yarn plus a tapestry kit I got a lot of surprises. This Red Heart Roll with It Sparkle skein in "Diamonds" was actually a cake that sells $10.99 on Yarnspirations. The lot included two Red Heart Super Saver Jumbo skeins, which retail for $8.99 each, and stuck in the center of the buff color I found a 5.5 mm crochet hook. This is a skein of 100% Icelandic wool, which can be really expensive. It's marked with a price tag of $7.00, and I found it selling for $8.00 online. The needlepoint kit is the biggest surprise of all. It makes a pillow, and hails from the UK, where it sells for £45.00 ($60.76 US). Since it's flamingos I definitely have to finish it if I can. Altogether my eight plus lot retails for $125.04; I paid $21.30 total for the lot with the buy-it-now option and one penny shipping. I indeed got a very nice bargain.

Not So Cheerful

Since I finished the January crazy-quilted tote for my calendar project I jumped back on making the Iris throw, working this time with Bernat Giggles in Cheerful Blue. From the start this skein seemed determined to give me trouble, not anything cheerful, as I had to contend with a big knot of yarn I tugged out along with the center pull strand (I didn't take a pic of that.) This yarn is 90% acrylic and 10% nylon, and come in a 3.5 oz. skein. Not sure why they added nylon to the acrylic, perhaps to make it softer. The color is nice, and it's fairly smooth, but it also splits easily and wants to pucker, pop and untwist, especially when you tear out stitches. Naturally I had to tear out two and a half rows to correct two mistakes, which aggravated me because the yarn was untwisting when I went to crochet it again. To add icing to this terrible cake, I ran out of the yarn on the final row. To keep the symmetry with the other sections I had to pull a compatible color fro...

Thrifty Crochet

Search This Blog